An Initiative of “SuryaShakthi Foundation” an NGO
An NGO registered as a Non-Profit Organisation under Section 8 of the Companies Act, 2013
How the System has Turned Borrowers into Untouchables & has Financially Paralysed them
Borrowing in India Has Become a One-Way Trap.
Harsh Penalties and Brutal Punishment
Borrowers who miss EMIs, even due to genuine hardships like health issues, job loss, or economic downturns, often face excessive penalties, soaring interest rates, and relentless harassment from collection agencies. Instead of structured support to help them recover, lenders escalate their financial distress by increasing the debt burden, sometimes leading to an inescapable cycle of repayment struggles.
Public Humiliation and Harassment
The shaming of defaulters is another cruel tactic banks and financial institutions employ. Borrowers have reported instances where recovery agents visit homes, workplaces, or even relatives’ houses, using intimidation to force repayments. In some cases, names are published publicly, tarnishing reputations and pushing individuals into deep emotional turmoil.
Weaponization of Credit Reports
Credit bureaus such as CIBIL, Experian, and CRIF create long-term consequences for borrowers who default or delay payments. While credit reporting is meant to assess financial responsibility, in reality, even minor delays can permanently ruin a person’s ability to access loans in the future. The system often lacks a fair and structured rehabilitation process, forcing borrowers into financial exile.
Permanent Financial Lockout
Once a borrower is branded as a defaulter, banks shut their doors, leading to a lifetime of exclusion from financial services. This means:
- No access to future business or personal loans.
- Difficulty in renting or buying properties due to bad credit.
- Struggles in securing financial partnerships or investments.
Instead of offering recovery mechanisms, such as debt restructuring programs or second-chance financial solutions, the system ensures that past missteps result in permanent financial exile.
The Root Cause: A System Designed for the Banks, Not the Borrowers
The financial ecosystem favours institutions over individuals, ensuring that banks minimize their risk at the cost of people’s livelihoods. Unlike more borrower-friendly models seen in Europe or the US, where financial missteps can be remedied over time, India’s system criminalizes financial difficulties instead of providing structured, ethical solutions.
The Problem Is Deeper than You Think
Credit Bureaus: The Unchecked Gatekeepers
India’s financial ecosystem is dominated by four major credit bureaus:
- CIBIL (Credit Information Bureau of India Limited)
- Equifax
- Experian
- CRIF High Mark
These bureaus collect, analyze, and assign credit scores based on borrowers’ past repayment behaviour. In theory, this system exists to assess risk for lenders, but in practice, it punishes borrowers permanently without oversight or a structured path for recovery.
How a Credit Score Can Ruin Your Life
The moment your credit score drops due to defaults, delays, or disputes, financial institutions blacklist you without considering the circumstances. The consequences extend far beyond loans:
- Denied Future Loans: No bank or lender will approve your application, locking you out of financial opportunities.
- Blocked Employment Prospects: Some employers conduct credit checks before hiring, considering low scores as signs of unreliability.
- Rental Rejections: Many landlords and commercial property owners use credit scores as a screening tool, making it difficult to rent a home or office space.
- Loss of Financial Access: Even basic banking services such as credit cards, overdraft facilities, and certain investment options may become inaccessible, pushing people further into economic hardship.
This turns past financial mistakes—often caused by life’s uncertainties—into a lifelong prison sentence.
The “Non-Creditworthy” Label: Worse Than a Criminal Tag
Unlike a criminal record that might allow rehabilitation over time, bad credit stays with you for years and has no guaranteed recovery path. In contrast:
- Convicts can rebuild their lives post-sentence, but borrowers remain punished indefinitely for a few missed payments.
- There is no standardized appeal system to dispute unfair reports—if a bureau wrongly penalizes you, there's no independent authority to audit or correct the error.
The Bigger Problem: No Oversight or Accountability
Unlike developed markets where regulators oversee credit reporting fairness, India’s credit bureaus operate unchecked. There’s no structured pathway for borrowers to recover, and dispute mechanisms are often slow, ineffective, or biased toward lenders.
- No Fair Auditing: There is no independent regulator questioning these practices.
- No Second Chances: No formal “credit rehabilitation” programs exist to help borrowers rebuild their profiles.
- Predatory Practices: Financial institutions often sell rejected borrowers’ information to aggressive lenders, pushing them toward expensive, exploitative loans.
Our mission to challenge systemic issues in business funding and advocate for fairness is directly linked to this flawed credit ecosystem. Exposing these issues, documenting real-life cases, and proposing viable solutions will be crucial in driving meaningful change.
Borrowers Are Being Treated Like Criminals
This is a brutal reality many borrowers in India face—one that goes beyond financial consequences and becomes a tool for public humiliation and psychological torment. Let’s break this down further.
Public Shaming Through Possession Notices
When borrowers default on loans, banks resort to publishing possession notices in newspapers, often with the person’s name, photo, and property details. These notices are placed in leading publications to ensure maximum public exposure, turning a financial difficulty into a public spectacle.
- Imagine losing your home AND waking up to see your name branded as a failure in newspapers read by millions
- The purpose is clear—not just repossessing the property, but destroying the person’s reputation permanently.
Aggressive Recovery Tactics: Harassment at Your Doorstep
Banks and lending institutions deploy recovery agents who use megaphones, drum beating, and direct threats outside borrowers’ homes to pressure them into repayment.
- Entire neighbourhoods are deliberately informed about the default, ensuring social isolation for the borrower.
- These tactics shatter dignity, pushing individuals into deep mental distress, and in some cases, leading to suicides.
This isn’t about financial responsibility—it’s about systematic destruction of a borrower’s social standing.
The “Defaulter” Label: A Sentence Without Trial
Once branded as a defaulter, there’s no escape:
- No future loans from banks or financial institutions.
- Employment struggles—some companies conduct credit checks before hiring.
- Destroyed credibility in business and personal transactions.
It’s not just economic loss. It’s forced societal exile, making it nearly impossible for individuals to recover or reintegrate.
The Systemic Problem: Why Is This Allowed?
India’s financial system places absolute power in the hands of banks and lenders, with little to no protection for borrowers. Unlike in the U.S. or Europe, where financial hardship can be managed through structured rehabilitation, Indian borrowers are:
- Punished relentlessly for events often beyond their control.
- Offered no second chances, making recovery impossible.
- Denied dignity, as if financial hardship equates to criminal behaviour.
We are trying to document unethical banking practices extensively—perhaps it’s time to take this narrative further into policy discussions, entrepreneur awareness workshops and legal activism.
Your Private Data Is No Longer Private
The Digital Footprint Trap: You Are Always Being Watched
Every financial transaction you make leaves a digital trace, including:
- Bank transactions: Deposits, withdrawals, and spending patterns.
- Online payments: Your purchases, subscriptions, and money transfers.
- Mobile data: Your location, browsing habits, and even app usage.
These institutions use AI-driven analytics to create detailed behavioral profiles—without explicit consent—allowing them to predict and control financial access.
Payment Behavior: Scored, Stored & Exploited
Your financial behavior is analyzed to determine:
- How frequently you borrow money
- How quickly you pay off debts
- Whether you delay payments or struggle financially
If you don’t match their “ideal” borrower profile, you could:
- How frequently you borrow money
- How quickly you pay off debts
- Whether you delay payments or struggle financially
This data-driven judgment system doesn’t consider personal struggles like job loss, emergencies, or health issues—it purely treats you as a financial asset or liability.
The Hidden Marketplace: Your Data Is Being Sold
Many fintech firms sell your financial profile to:
- Banks and lenders—who use it to determine creditworthiness.
- Debt collectors—who target those struggling with repayments.
- Advertising companies—who exploit spending habits for profit.
Without transparency, users have zero control over how their information is used—data that should be private is packaged and sold like a commodity.
The Consequences: Financial Discrimination, Stress & Social Exclusion
The result? A financial system that discriminates and excludes, leading to:
- Denied access to banking services, loans, or credit cards based on automated “risk scores.”
- Mental distress caused by financial surveillance, where individuals feel watched and judged
- Permanent exclusion from the financial ecosystem—a label that cannot be easily erased.
Instead of financial inclusion, this system pushes many into lifelong financial insecurity, affecting their personal life, career opportunities, and social standing.
This Broken System Must Be Challenged and we are doing exactly that
The System Doesn’t Differentiate Between Fraud & Failure
The banking & Financial ecosystem, rather than offering compassion and structured recovery, treats borrowers as Willful defaulters, regardless of the circumstances that led to financial difficulties.
No Mercy: Financial Institutions Assume the Worst
Lenders operate under a punitive framework, assuming every late payment or default is due to irresponsibility rather than hardship. This ignores genuine crises such as:
- Business failure: Entrepreneurs and small business owners are hit hardest, often losing everything in downturns—but instead of flexible restructuring, they face blacklisting.
- Medical emergencies: Life-threatening health issues can drain savings, but banks don’t acknowledge this—leading to foreclosures, loss of assets, and permanent financial exclusion.
- Job loss: Economic downturns, layoffs, or company closures force individuals into debt just to survive, but lenders escalate penalties instead of offering recovery programs.
- COVID disruption: Millions faced financial devastation, yet lending institutions refused leniency, trapping them in debt spirals.
- Instead of solutions, the system blames the borrower, ensuring that one financial setback becomes a permanent life sentence.
No Second Chance: Once You Default, You’re Marked Forever
Unlike in developed financial markets, where borrowers have rehabilitation pathways to rebuild credit, India’s system ensures:
- Once blacklisted, you’re permanently denied future loans.
- Credit bureaus ensure you remain “unfit” for financial services indefinitely.
- No structured financial recovery programs exist—only predatory loan offers.
Lenders make no distinction between life’s unavoidable hardships and reckless financial behaviour—instead, all defaults are treated as permanent failures.
No Fair Hearing: Borrowers Have No Voice
There is no standardized appeals system, meaning:
- If a dispute arises—whether due to fraud, banking errors, or unavoidable crises—the borrower is never heard.
- Banks make unilateral decisions on creditworthiness, often based on flawed or outdated data.
- Borrowers who attempt legal action find themselves buried under bureaucratic delays.
A System That Prefers Profit Over People
At its core, India’s financial structure is designed to protect lenders, not borrowers. Instead of risk-sharing models, ethical lending frameworks, or financial rehabilitation programs, it enforces punishment, exclusion, and shame.
No Way Back into the Mainstream System
No Mercy: Financial Institutions Assume the Worst
No Bank Wants to Talk to You
A dropped credit score immediately makes you a financial outcast. Banks treat it as an irreversible stain, meaning:
- Loan applications are rejected outright—no matter your actual financial situation.
- Even strong income or assets don’t matter—credit score takes precedence over everything.
- No opportunity to explain hardships—banks operate on numbers, not human circumstances.
What could have been a revolutionary financial inclusion tool has instead become an automated rejection system.
NBFCs: The Exploitative "Alternatives"
Once banks refuse to lend, borrowers turn to NBFCs (Non-Banking Financial Companies), but these institutions exploit desperation by charging:
- Sky-high interest rates—often double or triple the rates of traditional banks.
- Hidden fees—processing fees, documentation charges, and even penalty structures designed to keep borrowers trapped.
- Aggressive collection practices—some NBFCs mirror the worst tactics of banks, including harassment and legal threats.
Instead of offering ethical second-chance lending, NBFCs profit from the desperation of rejected borrowers.
Fintech Apps Reject You Automatically
The rise of AI-driven lending has created a system where:
- Algorithms analyze your financial patterns, rejecting borrowers with low credit scores instantly.
- No human review process exists, meaning life circumstances (health emergencies, job loss, etc.) are never considered.
- Financial decisions are made within seconds, permanently shutting people out with no appeals mechanism.
What could have been a revolutionary financial inclusion tool has instead become an automated rejection system.
Co-borrowers & Guarantors Are Also Punished
Even those who co-signed loans or guaranteed repayments suffer when a borrower defaults:
- Their own credit scores are damaged.
- They lose loan eligibility, even if their finances are stable.
- They become financially blacklisted, despite not being the primary borrower.
This system punishes entire families and business partnerships, making financial recovery impossible.
The Fundamental Problem: No Rehabilitation, No Second Chances
Unlike other developed financial systems, India offers no structured process for rebuilding credit. Borrowers get:
- No rehabilitation programs—other countries allow credit rebuilding after financial hardship.
- No financial counselling—banks provide no education on repairing financial health.
- No error correction system—credit bureaus rarely correct mistakes, even when borrowers dispute them.
- No second-chance loans—institutions refuse to consider past hardships, instead permanently rejecting applicants.
A System That Forces Borrowers into Lifelong Financial Exclusion
Once a borrower is branded as a “defaulter,” financial institutions make it nearly impossible to recover—turning a temporary financial setback into lifelong punishment.
The Cost of this Injustice
Lives Ruined: The Psychological & Social Toll
For many borrowers, financial difficulties aren’t a choice—they stem from unforeseen crises, such as job loss, medical emergencies, or economic downturns. But instead of assistance or rehabilitation, the system destroys them further, leading to:
- Mental health deterioration—anxiety, depression, and even suicide.
- Loss of dignity—public humiliation, constant harassment, and financial blacklisting.
- Forced isolation—borrowers lose social standing, trust, and community support.
Rather than helping individuals rebuild, the system ensures they never recover, turning financial misfortune into permanent personal devastation.
Families Broken: The Ripple Effect
A financial default doesn’t just affect the borrower—it destroys entire families:
- Spouses suffer emotionally and financially, often taking on burdens they can’t handle.
- Children’s futures are impacted, with education loans, opportunities, and security lost.
- Elderly dependents face hardships, as financial constraints force families into difficult decisions.
Instead of structured financial relief, families are left to fend for themselves, often falling into lifelong debt traps.
Reputations Destroyed: The Permanent Stigma
Unlike other life struggles, financial setbacks come with social consequences:
- Banks and recovery agents actively shame borrowers, spreading defaulter labels in neighbourhoods and workplaces.
- Employers may deny jobs based on credit history, destroying career opportunities.
- Credit bureaus ensure a single financial misstep defines individuals for decades, making rebuilding nearly impossible.
A temporary hardship turns into lifelong financial exile, where people are forced into irreversible loss.
Entrepreneurs Forced to Shut Down
For business owners, financial difficulties aren’t just personal—they destroy enterprises, leading to:
- Loss of jobs for employees.
- Closure of innovative ventures.
- Blacklisting from future funding opportunities.
Instead of supporting entrepreneurs through structured recovery, banks and NBFCs eliminate them from the system, ensuring their past mistakes become permanent barriers.
Citizens Denied Access to Their Own Country’s Financial System
Once a person’s credit score drops, they are locked out of financial inclusion entirely:
- No access to basic loans, business funding, or credit facilities.
- No ability to rent or buy properties.
- No recognition of past financial contributions or responsible payments.
A financial system designed to serve people should allow recovery and second chances—instead, it forces permanent exclusion, treating borrowers like criminals.
The System Refuses to Reform
Rather than designing solutions that acknowledge human struggles, economic fluctuations, and unforeseen emergencies, banks, NBFCs, and credit bureaus punish borrowers indefinitely:
- No structured rehabilitation for financial recovery.
- No transparent dispute resolution for unfair credit penalties.
- No ethical lending frameworks to prevent lifelong exclusion.
Instead of helping individuals overcome difficulties, the system ensures that a temporary crisis becomes a permanent life sentence.
This Is Not Just a Financial Problem.
Violation of Right to Privacy
Banks, fintech companies, and credit bureaus collect and share financial data without full transparency or consent. Borrowers’ financial behavior—including transactions, borrowing history, and spending habits—is:
- Tracked without explicit approval
- Stored indefinitely, even after debts are cleared
- Shared with third parties, including lenders, insurers, and advertisers
This breach of privacy means that individuals no longer control their own financial identities—institutions dictate access based on a data-driven scoring system.
Violation of Right to Dignity
The treatment of defaulters goes beyond financial penalties—it becomes public humiliation:
- Banks publish possession notices with names and photos in newspapers
- Recovery agents harass borrowers in their homes and workplaces
- Neighbourhoods are alerted about defaulters, turning communities against them
Instead of structured financial solutions, banks shame borrowers publicly, stripping them of basic dignity—a fundamental human right.
Denial of Right to Equality
Financial institutions enforce discriminatory barriers based on credit scores:
- Rejected loan applications, regardless of income or business potential
- Blocked access to renting homes or office spaces
- Denied employment opportunities due to financial history
Credit scores override factors like skill, experience, and integrity, ensuring that those who experience financial hardship are permanently excluded—a direct violation of equal opportunity.
Breach of Data Protection Laws
Despite laws intended to protect financial data, institutions operate with impunity:
- Data is shared across banks, lenders, and fintech platforms without full user control.
- Credit reports are difficult to dispute, even when errors exist.
- Borrowers cannot erase past mistakes from financial records, despite debt resolution.
In a truly ethical financial system, borrowers would have the right to protect and control their own data—but today, they have no say in how their financial profile is used.
Discrimination Based on Digital Blacklisting
Once someone defaults or delays payments, they are digitally blacklisted:
- No second-chance lending—banks refuse future financing.
- NBFCs exploit them with predatory interest rates.
- Fintech algorithms reject applications automatically, without human review.
Instead of a system where borrowers can recover, India enforces permanent financial exile, treating people like lifelong criminals for temporary setbacks.
Abuse of Power and Public Platforms
Banks and credit bureaus use their power unchecked, with no formal system for borrower protection:
- Credit bureaus control financial access without independent audits.
- Loan recovery tactics include public harassment and social humiliation.
- Banks operate without structured rehabilitation programs, ensuring lifelong exclusion.
This isn’t just financial injustice—it’s systemic control over people’s ability to build their futures, with zero accountability.
Our Advocacy Could Drive Change
We have been extensively documenting these flaws, and our work in challenging systemic banking issues directly ties into this human rights crisis.
“India cannot call itself inclusive until it protects its borrowers from systemic abuse.”
“Justice delayed is dignity denied.”
It’s time to fix the system. It’s time to demand justice. It’s time to fight for every borrower who was cast aside.
We are calling for something truly necessary—a financial revolution that restores dignity, fairness, and opportunity for borrowers who have been wrongfully cast aside. The current system thrives on exclusion rather than rehabilitation, turning temporary hardships into lifelong punishments. It’s time to demand justice, challenge systemic failures, and build a better financial future.
The financial industry needs structural reform to ensure borrowers aren’t treated like criminals for facing life’s uncertainties. A fair system would:
- Introduce rehabilitation programs—structured opportunities for borrowers to rebuild their financial standing.
- Implement borrower protection laws—limiting harassment, public shaming, and punitive credit policies.
- Audit credit bureaus for transparency—ensuring errors are corrected and credit rebuilding is possible.
- Regulate NBFCs and predatory fintech lenders—preventing exploitative interest rates and financial abuse.
Once a borrower is branded as a “defaulter,” financial institutions make it nearly impossible to recover—turning a temporary financial setback into lifelong punishment.
Demanding Justice: Holding Financial Institutions Accountable
Lenders and credit bureaus operate without oversight, often making arbitrary decisions that permanently impact people’s lives. Justice requires:
- Legal advocacy for fair credit reporting—challenging unfair credit score practices.
- Transparent policies in debt restructuring—so borrowers facing crisis aren’t permanently excluded.
- Protection against financial harassment—ending unethical recovery tactics.
- Financial inclusion laws—ensuring second chances for borrowers rather than digital blacklisting.
Without accountability, financial institutions will continue to use unchecked power—it’s time to push for policy changes, legal actions, and borrower protections.
Fighting for Borrowers: Building Ethical Alternatives
If banks refuse to change, entrepreneurs and advocates must create better alternatives:
- Ethical lending platforms—funding models based on trust and transparency, rather than exploitation.
- Entrepreneur-backed financial support systems—business owners helping fellow entrepreneurs with fair financing solutions.
- Community-driven funding models—peer-to-peer lending, credit unions, or ethical investment networks.
- Public campaigns and education—spreading awareness to protect borrowers from abusive financial systems.
The fight isn’t just about fixing banks—it’s about building new financial frameworks that empower rather than punish.
“Justice for Credit Borrowers is an initiative of
Surya Shakthi Foundation”
to know more, visit www.suryashakthi.org.
About Us
Justice for Credit Borrowers is a powerful citizens’ initiative launched by the Surya Shakthi Foundation, a NGO registered as a Non-Profit organization under the Section 8 of the Companies Act 2013 and committed to social justice, financial inclusion, and human dignity.
About Suryashakthi
To learn more about our legal standing, governance, and broader activities, please visit our official NGO website: www.suryashakthi.org
Quick Links
Address
No 248, “Brindavan Elite” Apt 202
III Main Road, Panduranganagar
JP Nagar 7th Phase
Bengaluru – 560076
Karnataka State, INDIA